| Through Week 13 of 2023 Season | Single | |||||||||
| Single | Game | |||||||||
| Game Pass | Passing | |||||||||
| Rank | Name | Year | Opponent | Completions | Rank | Name | Year | Opponent | Yards | |
| 1 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Kirtland | 26 | 1 | Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Parkway | 456 | |
| 2 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Marion Local | 25 | 2 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Kirtland | 418 | |
| 3 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Sidney Lehman | 23 | 3 | Josh Nixon | 2013 | Sidney Lehman | 368 | |
| Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Fort Loramie | 23 | 4 | Josh Nixon | 2013 | Anna | 366 | ||
| 5 | Adam Niemeyer | 2009 | Parkway | 21 | 5 | Josh Nixon | 2015 | St. Henry | 339 | |
| Josh Nixon | 2013 | Sidney Lehman | 21 | 6 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Sidney Lehman | 338 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | St. Henry | 21 | 7 | Brogan Stephey | 2022 | St. Henry | 317 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | Anna | 21 | 8 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | West Liberty-Salem | 304 | ||
| 9 | Adam Niemeyer | 2011 | Marion Local | 20 | 9 | Josh Nixon | 2015 | Fort Loramie | 291 | |
| Josh Nixon | 2013 | Anna | 20 | 10 | Josh Nixon | 2015 | DeGraff Riverside | 287 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2014 | Anna | 20 | 11 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Fort Loramie | 284 | ||
| Brogan Stephey | 2022 | St. Henry | 20 | 12 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Versailles | 282 | ||
| 13 | Matt Quinter | 1998 | Marion Local | 19 | Jared Huelsman | 2016 | Fort Recovery | 282 | ||
| Chase Paxson | 2010 | Marion Local | 19 | 14 | Brogan Stephey | 2021 | Anna | 281 | ||
| Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Anna | 19 | 15 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Mechanicsburg | 280 | ||
| 16 | Chase Paxson | 2010 | New Bremen | 18 | 16 | Tony Hemmelgarn | 1982 | Delphos St. Johns | 279 | |
| Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Coldwater | 18 | 17 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Versailles | 273 | ||
| Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Versailles | 18 | 18 | Jacob Niemeyer | 2018 | Covington | 267 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2013 | Fort Recovery | 18 | 19 | James Niemeyer | 2023 | New Bremen | 265 | ||
| Jared Huelsman | 2016 | Fort Recovery | 18 | 20 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Tri-County North | 264 | ||
| Jacob Niemeyer | 2019 | Anna | 18 | 21 | Jacob Niemeyer | 2019 | Anna | 263 | ||
| Brogan Stephey | 2021 | New Bremen | 18 | 22 | Josh Nixon | 2015 | Parkway | 258 | ||
| James Niemeyer | 2023 | New Bremen | 18 | 23 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Anna | 254 | ||
| 24 | Chase Paxson | 2010 | Fort Loramie | 17 | 24 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Marion Local | 250 | |
| Josh Nixon | 2013 | Delphos St. Johns | 17 | Josh Nixon | 2013 | Fort Recovery | 250 | |||
| Josh Nixon | 2014 | Fort Loramie | 17 | Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Fort Loramie | 250 | |||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | Sidney Lehman | 17 | 27 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Sidney Lehman | 248 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | Parkway | 17 | Brogan Stephey | 2021 | Columbus Crusaders | 248 | |||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | Fort Recovery | 17 | 29 | Jared Huelsman | 2017 | Versailles | 246 | ||
| Jared Huelsman | 2016 | Anna | 17 | 30 | Chase Paxson | 2008 | Parkway | 237 | ||
| Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Parkway | 17 | Adam Niemeyer | 2009 | Parkway | 237 | |||
| Brogan Stephey | 2022 | New Bremen | 17 | 32 | Josh Nixon | 2013 | Coldwater | 235 | ||
| Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Fort Loramie | 17 | 33 | Corky Poeppelman | 1972 | Parkway | 234 | ||
| 34 | Austin Baumer | 2007 | St. Henry | 16 | 34 | Josh Nixon | 2014 | Fort Recovery | 231 | |
| Chase Paxson | 2010 | Sidney Lehman | 16 | 35 | Dustin Sommer | 1982 | New Bremen | 230 | ||
| Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Tri-County North | 16 | Josh Nixon | 2013 | Delphos St. Johns | 230 | |||
| Josh Nixon | 2014 | Fort Recovery | 16 | 37 | Brogan Stephey | 2022 | New Bremen | 228 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2014 | Mechanicsburg | 16 | 38 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Versailles | 224 | ||
| Josh Nixon | 2015 | DeGraff Riverside | 16 | Jacob Niemeyer | 2019 | St. Henry | 224 | |||
| Jared Huelsman | 2017 | Fort Recovery | 16 | 40 | Tim Stueve | 1999 | Marion Local | 223 | ||
| Jacob Niemeyer | 2018 | Delphos St. Johns | 16 | Chase Paxson | 2010 | Fort Loramie | 223 | |||
| Jacob Niemeyer | 2019 | Delphos St. Johns | 16 | 42 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Anna | 221 | ||
| Jacob Niemeyer | 2019 | Marion Local | 16 | Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Fort Recovery | 221 | |||
| Johnny Nixon | 2020 | St. Henry | 16 | Josh Nixon | 2015 | Delphos St. Johns | 221 | |||
| Brogan Stephey | 2023 | Marion Local | 16 | 45 | Jacob Niemeyer | 2018 | DeGraff Riverside | 218 | ||
| James Niemeyer | 2023 | Versailles | 16 | Johnny Nixon | 2020 | Parkway | 218 | |||
| 47 | Corky Poeppelman | 1972 | Parkway | 15 | 47 | Scott Sherman | 2002 | Fort Recovery | 217 | |
| Chase Paxson | 2008 | Versailles | 15 | Johnny Nixon | 2020 | St. Henry | 217 | |||
| Adam Niemeyer | 2012 | Delphos St. Johns | 15 | Brogan Stephey | 2022 | Fort Loramie | 217 | |||
| Josh Nixon | 2013 | Coldwater | 15 | 50 | Chase Paxson | 2010 | Fort Recovery | 216 | ||